A WORLD OF WOMEN WRITERS

Mugs

Mugs from the Silver Moon Bookshop showing a world of women writers

In the nineties I worked at the Silver Moon Women’s Bookshop on the Charing Cross Road in London. It was the largest women’s bookshop in Europe and one of the items we sold was mugs, listing the names of women writers. I came across a couple of these the other day in the back of the cupboard and looked at them with a curious and critical eye. The decision about who to list must have been made close to when the shop first opened in 1984 and I thought it might be interesting for the purposes of this blog to draw up my own list of 33 (that’s the number of names listed) and see who I’d keep from the original list, who I was horrified not to see on the list and and who in current times would definitely have to be on it. Please join me in twisting your fork into this highly subjective plate of literary spaghetti.

First a list of the original names:

MAYA ANGELOU, MARGARET ATWOOD, ANGELA CARTER, WILLA CATHER, SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR, MARGARET DRABBLE, MARGUERITE DURAS, GEORGE ELIOT, BUCHI EMECHETA, JANET FRAME, MARILYN FRENCH, NANCY FRIDAY, MARTHA GELLHORN, SUE GRAFTON, GERMAINE GREER, RADCLYFFE HALL, JUNE JORDAN, DORIS LESSING, AUDRE LORDE, TERRY MCMILLAN, TONI MORRISON, IRIS MURDOCH, ANAIS NIN. SYLVIA PLATH, MARGE PIERCY, SARA PARETSKY, RUTH RENDELL, NAWAL EL SAADAWI, SARAH SCHULMAN, GERTRUDE STEIN, ANNE TYLER, ALICE WALKER, E. H. YOUNG.

The ones I would definitely keep from the original list I’ve marked in red. It’s eleven of them, a third of the total.

I then began to consider what writers you would simply have to have in there who are not there at the moment and these are the ones I thought of: BERYL BAINBRIDGE, PAT BARKER, ELENA FERRANTE, HILARY MANTEL, J.K. ROWLING, ALI SMITH, ZADIE SMITH, SARAH WATERS, JEANETTE WINTERSON.

So that brings the number up to 20.

Thirteen more to go.

But then I had a startling realization – no JANE AUSTEN, no CHARLOTTE, EMILY, ANNE, BRONTE,  no VIRGINIA WOOLF, no HARPER LEE. What were they thinking of! E. H. Young but no Virginia! I should admit at this point, by the way, that I am ashamed to say the only Woolf book I have ever completed is To the Lighthouse and that is because I had to read it at A’Level and I never got over the death of Mrs Ramsay. I love Woolf’s letters, although it made me realize that going to tea with her would be about as enjoyable as swimming with sharks. But she has to be on there, doesn’t she?

So, if I add in Jane Austen, one of the Brontes (sweat beads brow – oh God which one!) and Virginia Woolf then I have a list of 23.

So I have ten to play with.

At this point the breakdown is:13 British, 6 American, 1 Australian, 1 Canadian, 1 South African, 1 Italian,  and my world is looking a bit narrow and a bit white. So what did I do next?

Here is my final highly subjective choice which includes two more from the original 33: My aim was to create a list of excellent women writers and cover a range of eras, sexualities, ethnic origins and nationalities.

MAYA ANGELOU, MARGARET ATWOOD, JANE AUSTEN, BERYL BAINBRIDGE, PAT BARKER, SIMONE DE BEAUVOIR, ALISON BECHDEL, CHARLOTTE BRONTE,  RENI EDDO-LODGE, NAWAL EL SAADAWI, GEORGE ELIOT, BUCHI EMECHETA, ELENA FERRANTE, ROXANE GAY, GERMAINE GREER, RADCLYFFE HALL, HAN KANG, HARPER LEE, DORIS LESSING, HILARY MANTEL, TONI MORRISON, HERTA MULLER, CHIMOMANDA NGOZI ADICHIE, SYLVIA PLATH, MARILYN ROBINSON, J.K. ROWLING, ARUNDHATI ROY, ALI SMITH, ZADIE SMITH, GERTRUDE STEIN, ALICE WALKER, SARAH WATERS, JEANETTE WINTERSON

THE FINAL BREAKDOWN:

NATIONALITIES: British – 14, American – 9, Italian – 1, South Korean – 1, Roumanian – 1, Egyptian – 1, Nigerian – 1, French – 1, Australian – 1, Indian – 1, Canadian – 1, South African – 1

ETHNICITY: White – 22, African American – 4 BAME –  3, Indian – 1, Egyptian – 1, Nigerian – 1, South Korean – 1

ALIVE OR DEAD?: Alive – 23, Dead – 10.

GAY/STRAIGHT: Gay (as far as I’m aware!) – 7, Straight – 26

What do you think of my choices? Too British, too white, too straight, too dead? Or perhaps too alive! And would you buy my (hypothetical) mug? Have I got a good balance? Tell me all in the comments below. But here’s the thing, if you suggest someone who should be on there, you have to take someone off. Those are the rules. Have fun. And before you start in, I know I’m lacking a crime writer and a science fiction writer, although Atwood could be called a science fiction writer at a pinch. I thought of getting rid of Doris in exchange for Agatha or Val but Doris won the Nobel Prize, so even if I don’t find reading her a pleasure, she has to stay in, doesn’t she?

And to help you out or perhaps derange you, here is a pool of writers I thought about but did not in the end include. These do not include the ones on the original mug that I didn’t retain, who you can of course argue the case for, and anyone else if it comes to that:

NAOMI ALDERMAN, KATE ATKINSON, MARY BEARD, MALORIE BLACKMAN, EMILY BRONTE, A.S.BYATT, JULIA CAMERON, AGATHA CHRISTIE, HELEN DUNMORE, BERNADINE EVARISTO, P.D. JAMES, OLIVIA LAING, URSULA LE GUIN, ANDREA LEVY, HELEN MCDONALD, VAL MCDERMID, EDNA O’BRIEN, SUSIE ORBACH, ALICE OSWALD, ANNIE PROULX,  BARBARA PYM, CLAUDIA RANKINE, MARY RENAULT, JEAN RHYS, JANE SMILEY, MEERA SYAL, MURIEL SPARK, KATE TEMPEST, ROSE TREMAIN, ALISON WEIR, EUDORA WELTY, JAQUELINE WILSON. 

The best comment will win one of these mugs. They are not exactly in peak condition but have a few more years of life left in them yet. I’m afraid this only applies to the UK. I’ll leave the comments open for two weeks and announce the winner then. Have fun!

P.S. Just realized I left out Carol Ann Duffy. She has to be in doesn’t she? Gertrude might have to go!

11 thoughts on “A WORLD OF WOMEN WRITERS

  1. I think Lionel Shriver might be a bit miffed but c’est la vie, Lio. I’d keep Ms Murdoch in because she changed my reading habits and made me believe I might become a writer. And to add an Aussie bent, I’d put in Miles Franklin, feminist and the name given to our most prestigious literary prize… Not sure who I’d eliminate, though.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Madame Bibi fashion is a fickle thing in the literary world and it’s interesting to see which ones of the originals hold up as being ones I felt I could not get rid of and the one (Margaret Drabble) that I struck off without a thought! Some of this is effected by TV/FILM. For example Atwood and The Handmaid’s Tale is very current. Deciding on only one Bronte produced a heated discussion with my partner as to the merits of Cathy in Wuthering Heights over Jane Eyre. I mean you can’t have two Brontes on a cup can you? There is something innately ridiculous about these kind of lists but there we go. The silly season is beckoning! I can scent it in the air.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’d dump Adichie and Roy since they’ve both annoyed me. And I’d get rid of de Beauvoir because no-one should ever be made to read feminist literature. *ducks to avoid missiles* Oops! I guess that mean Gertrude is for the chop too!

    In – Agatha Christie, of course! How could you even think of leaving her out?? Daphne du Maurier. Denise Mina. And Val McDermid. Or maybe Shirley Jackson.

    I often wonder what would happen if I opened a bookshop that only sold books by men… 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi FF and thanks for playing along even though being dubious about the whole thing. I agree on Christie and Val and I was tempted by du Maurier having just re-read Rebecca and having particularly enjoyed the point where Maxim files his nails at the breakfast table. Strangely enough not included by Hitchcock in the film. I haven’t read any Shirley Jackson and only one Denise Mina – her first one I think. But who would I ditch? I have a fondness for Stein’s Blood on the Dining Room Floor although maybe that’s just because it reminds me of family Christmases! De Beauvoir I could definitely get rid of without too much of a qualm. The shop closed in 2001 done for by increase of rents in central London and it’s now a Chinese Medecine centre!

      Liked by 1 person

  3. This is a really interesting list – many of the women on it were seen as classic feminist authors when I was doing Women’s Studies in the early 90s – Marylin French, Audre Lorde, Marge Piercy…but perhaps haven’t stood the test of time? I would include Daphne Du Maurier I think – and it will be interesting to see how some of the more modern authors like Ali Smith, Zadie Smith and Hilary Mantel fare in the years to come…

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi Andrea that’s interesting. I wonder what the reading list for a current women’s study list would look like. I was surprised that Susie Orbach’s Fat is a Feminist Issue wasn’t on there because it seems to me that book has stood the test of time and it was first published in 1978. It’s also curious that Ruth Rendell is on there but not Agatha. I feel that I should have got Sara Paretsky onto my list as well, not to mention Carol Ann Duffy. Maybe I need a bigger mug!

      Liked by 1 person

  4. I think you have an impossible task!
    I’m glad a couple of your other followers have suggested Du Maurier – I thought I might be considered to populist. It is one of the eternal mysteries of my life that 2 of my oldest friends write fiction and I hardly ever read it(!) So some of the names I have never even heard of.
    You absolutely cannot remove Gertrude. I found her so liberating and took her style into the one book I have written. Really thrilled to see Ms Cameron there – she wrote my artist bible. And Ms Duffy – Medusa continues to send shivers down my spine.
    Perhaps next time they produce a mug there will be a V Blake on it …

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hello darling and thank you for joining in. I blame the heat for frying my brains! It was a real head banger and then I forgot Carol Ann Duffy, the first woman poet laureate! So someone to stand up for Gertrude – excellent! She is highly original. As for Du Maurier I re-read Rebecca recently and it’s such a gothic, febrile wonder. Of course the real love affair is with the house not Maxim. As for Mrs D …. so gloriously ‘deviant’ in the campest possible way! Unfortunately I think I’ve got rather a long way to go before I could contemplate my name on there!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s